Warren Carlyle, the Tony Award-nominated director-choreographer of After Midnight, won the Astaire Award for Outstanding Choreographer for a Broadway show, while After Midnight cast members Dormeshia Sumbry Edwards and Karine Plantadit tied for Outstanding Female Dancer in a Broadway Show, and Jared Grimes won for Outstanding Male Dancer in a Broadway Show. After Midnight was the most-nominated production of the Astaire Awards season.

Here is a list of the 2014 Astaire nominees