Watch Broadway Musicals: A Jewish Legacy (Happy New Year!)

“What do the following have in common: Irving Berlin, George and Ira Gershwin, Richard Rodgers, Lorenz Hart, Oscar Hammerstein, Leonard Bernstein, Stephen Sondheim, the list goes on and on? Yes, they’re musical titans every one. And they also happen to be Jewish.”

So begins “Broadway Musicals: A Jewish Legacy,” a 90-minute documentary that you can watch at the link (the movie begins after the 8:40 mark.) First broadcast on PBS in 2013, the show feels like an appropriate gift for the Jewish new year, 5785.

Why were so many of Broadway songwriters in the twentieth century Jewish?

The documentary suggests several factors, as the documentary’s filmmaker Michael Kantor has explained: “It’s Yiddish theater, it’s Jewish liturgical music that feeds into great Broadway shows, it’s a Jewish ethos that says we’re not just going to amuse you but we’re going to instruct you: If you behave a certain way, you can get the girl, you can win. America is a place where that optimism will reign…These are children of immigrants who want to master the language….”

The film, narrated by Joel Grey, features interviews with dozens of composers (some — like John Kander, Stephen Schwartz, Marc Shaiman and Maury Yeston — at their piano), historians, critics, and relatives of the greats; as well as performances by David Hyde Pierce (Spamalot), Matthew Broderick and Kelli O’Hara (Nice Work if You Can Get It), Zero Mostel (Fiddler on the Roof), Betty Comden and Adolph Green (On the Town), Nathan Lane (The Producers), Al Jolson (Sinbad), Fanny Brice (The Great Ziegfeld), Barbra Streisand (Funny Girl), Grey himself (Cabaret), Dick Van Dyke (Bye Bye Birdie), Danny Kaye (Lady in the Dark), Ethel Merman (Gypsy.) It offers portraits of some of the best-known of the Jewish composers with some fascinating anecdotes.

We’re told that Cole Porter, the most obvious example of a successful Broadway composer who was not Jewish, told Richard Rodgers that the secret to his hits was that he had figured out how to write “Jewish tunes.”

George Gershwin tried to write for Yiddish theater, but was rejected as too American

Gershwin made his mission to incorporate blues, jazz and ragtime — Black music — into the mainstream Broadway musical. There was already an affinity between the Jewish and the African-American musical tradition; poet David Lehman points to the use in both traditions of the minor key. Indeed, for “Porgy and Bess,” the Gershwins adapted the music from a standard Hebrew prayer for use in “It Ain’t Necessarily So” — “To borrow a prayer over the Bible for a song that debunks the Bible seems to me to be the definition of chutzpah,” Lehman says.

Though the majority of Broadway composers throughout the twentieth century were Jewish, it wasn’t until 1964 that any of them created a musical specifically about Jews, “Fiddler on the Roof.” Even then, says lyricist Sheldon Harnick, “many people said ‘oh you’re so brave.'”

A partial list of Jewish songwriters who had at least one show on Broadway

  • Harold Arlen
  • Burt Bacharach
  • Lionel Bart
  • Alan and Marilyn Bergman
  • Irving Berlin
  • Leonard Bernstein
  • Don Black
  • Jerry Bock
  • Alain Boublil
  • Sammy Cahn
  • Eric Carmen
  • Leonard Cohen
  • Cy Coleman
  • Betty Comden
  • Hal David
  • Howard Dietz
  • Ervin Drake
  • Al Dubin
  • Isaak Dunaevsky
  • Fred Ebb
  • Ray Evans
  • Sammy Fain
  • Dorothy Fields
  • Charles Fox
  • George and Ira Gershwin
  • Norman Gimbel
  • Adolph Green
  • Johnny Green
  • Marvin Hamlisch
  • E. Y. Harburg
  • Sheldon Harnick
  • Lorenz Hart
  • Jerry Herman
  • James Horner
  • Billy Joel
  • John Kander
  • Jerome Kern
  • Carole King
  • Herbert Kretzmer
  • Burton Lane
  • Jerry Leiber
  • Mitch Leigh
  • Alan Jay Lerner
  • Jay Livingston
  • Frank Loesser
  • Johnny Mandel
  • Barry Mann
  • Melissa Manchester
  • Barry Manilow
  • Michael Masser
  • Alan Menken
  • Randy Newman
  • Richard Rodgers
  • Sigmund Romberg
  • Harold Rome
  • Carole Bayer Sager
  • Claude-Michel Schönberg 
  • Arthur Schwartz
  • Stephen Schwartz
  • Paul Simon
  • Stephen Sondheim
  • Mike Stoller
  • Charles Strouse
  • Jule Styne
  • Cynthia Weil
  • Kurt Weill
  • Frank Wildhorn
  • Maury Yeston
  • Victor Young

Author: New York Theater

Jonathan Mandell is a 3rd generation NYC journalist, who sees shows, reads plays, writes reviews and sometimes talks with people.

Leave a Reply