The Woodsman Review: How The Tin Man of Oz Lost His Heart

The Woodsman, a nearly wordless play with puppets that tells the story of how the Tin Man from the Wizard of Oz lost both his human body and his heart, arrives at New World Stages after several previous runs that were praised as charming and magical. So why did I fantasize dousing the cast with a bucket of water?

I felt tremendous guilt about this mischievous urge to add a little slapstick to the noble artistry, which seems tantamount to kicking a litter of puppies, or, more precisely, tripping a mime. There is no question that Strangemen & Co.’s 70-minute staging of one of L. Frank Baum’s fairy tales is heartfelt, and beautiful to look at; that James Ortiz – who wrote the adaptation, designed the set and puppets, portrays the title character, and co-directs the production – is deeply talented; that the nine other performers, including violinist Naomi Florin, are a dedicated ensemble, who even breathe as if one: We see their unified breath at both the beginning and the end of the show.

After they breathe, in a brief prologue Ortiz poetically sums up L. Frank Baum’s tale, before they all act it out silently, accompanied by Florin’s persistently plaintive violin and an occasional dirge-like song (the original music is written by Edward W. Hardy). Nick Chopper (Ortiz) is a regular human being who is engaged to be married to a pretty Munchkin girl named Nimmee. But Nimmee  (Eliza Simpson) is slave to the Witch (a striking puppet manipulated by Amanda Lederer and Sophia Zukoski.) The Witch disapproves of the couple’s love, and invests Nick’s axe with the magical ability to chop him to pieces. Friendly neighborhood Tinkers replace each body part as it is severed with a tin prosthetic, until the woods man has become the tin man (the second puppet). At the end, the tin man is stuck alone in one of the bare branches, but suddenly a house comes clattering onto the stage, and out of it pops a bright-eyed young girl.

It should be noted that Dorothy is wearing the original silver slippers rather than the ruby slippers introduced by Judy Garland. “The Woodsman” has too much integrity to allow any Hollywood touches into this dark tale. So everything is tasteful and inventive, languid and lovely, artistic and, to me, a tad tedious.  It’s not their fault that I left feeling like W.C. Fields, wondering if Toto’s origin story is next.

The Woodsman
New World Stages
By James Ortiz, adapted from L. Frank Baum
Music composed by Edward W. Hardy, lyrics by Jen Loring
Directed by James Ortiz and Claire Karpen
Set and puppet design by James Ortiz, costume design by Molly Seidel, lighting design by Catherine Clark and Jamie Roderick
Cast: Benjamin Bass, Devin Dunne Cannon, Will Gallacher, Alex J. Gould, Amanda A. Lederer, Aaron McDaniel, Lauren Nordvig, James Oritz, Eliza Simpson, Meghan St. Thomas, Sophia Zukoski
Running time: 70 minutes with no intermission
Tickets: $45 to $85

Author: New York Theater

Jonathan Mandell is a 3rd generation NYC journalist, who sees shows, reads plays, writes reviews and sometimes talks with people.

2 thoughts on “The Woodsman Review: How The Tin Man of Oz Lost His Heart

  1. Jonathan: I quite often rely on your reviews as I have many times agreed with your reactions to a good many shows. While I appreciated this review of “The Woodsman,” I don’t quite get your reference to wanting to blast the cast from a water hose. I somehow can’t figure out what you or they would gain from being blasted from a rubber hose. Is this a common phrase I am not familiar with? It seems clear you are not a great fan of origin stories (especially from a story that has so many characters who could each have their own separate origin story–with or without puppets! I certainly don’t blame you and frankly haven’t there been a few too many riffs on The Wizard of Oz?

  2. Thank you for reading my reviews. I apologize for my failed effort at levity. What I was trying to say was that the show was so gentle and artistic and even virtuous that it made me fantasize doing some mischief to break up the tedium — such as dousing the cast with water. (I’ve changed the wording a bit in hopes of making this clearer.)

Leave a Reply