Escape or engage? That seems to be the choice in the shows that opened in the past week: You could spend time in an elegant English drawing room or on Death Row. It’s more or less the choice that continues this week among the six (!) shows — two plays, four musicals — that are opening on Broadway through April 26, finishing up the Broadway 2025-2026 season.
Below: This season’s Broadway reading list, current theater trends, a glimpse at next season (Billy Crystal’s new one-man show, Roundabout’s Broadway and Off-Broadway plays and musicals PAC NYC’s theater offerings), videos of the Olivier Awards, and a Sunday Morning interview with Don Cheadle and Ayo Edebiri of Proof.
The Week in New York Theater Reviews
Adrien Brody in his Broadway debut tells the true story of a man who spent more than two decades on Death Row for a murder he did not commit. Lindsey Ferrentino’s play is also the story of a jailhouse romance, featuring Tessa Thompson, also making her Broadway debut; it is something of an adventure story as well, and the story of the modern miracle of DNA testing, and of the cruelty of prison life and the incompetence of the criminal justice system. But, above all, “The Fear of 13” is a story about a storyteller.
“The more ludicrous your stories are, the more I find out they’re true,” Thompson as Jacki Miles, a prison volunteer, says to Brody as Nick Yarris
Off The Record: Acts of Restorative Justice
I attended “Off The Record” the same week as “The Fear of 13,” both of which are about the failings of the American criminal justice system. The self-described ‘”theatrical intervention” Off-Off Broadway could almost serve as a talk back for the Broadway play, which dramatizes a specific true story about a man unjustly imprisoned…less a conventional work of theater than ninety minutes of riffs — statistics, historical facts, political rants, a role-playing demonstration, audience Q&As, and monologues by metaphorical characters named The Conductor, The System and The Magician. presented vaguely like circus performers (with James Scruggs as the MC), as if that is the best way to describe Law and Order in America.
Both Don Cheadle and Ayo Edebiri are making their Broadway debuts in this first Broadway revival of David Auburn’s play about a family of mathematicians — the father a genius who became mentally ill; the daughter afraid that she too is both….the casting shifts the emphasis in this production in a couple of ways, one obviously and intentionally, the other surely not.
Kelli O’Hara’s drunken pratfalls, along with Rose Byrne’s wildly skewed wig, mark the high point in the low comedy that most distinguishes this century-old trifle, written by a young Noel Coward as an attempt at a scandalous French farce for the English stage…the main draw of this production are the two poised and celebrated actresses, and the main pleasure is watching them dive ass-first into the slapstick.
The Week in New York Theater News
Reading Broadway: The Books behind the 2025-2026 Season
Billy Crystal will return to Broadway in October in a new one-man show, 860, “the address of the home we lost in the Palisades fires. We lived there for 46 years. I invite you to come inside 860 and I’ll tell you all the funny and touching things that happened there.”
Theater Trends
Two April 14th Tragedies Now Broadway Punchlines
What does it say about us that every night on Broadway, theatergoers now gather to laugh at two terrible American tragedies, both of which occurred on April 14. John Wilkes Booth assassinated President Abraham Lincoln on April 14, 1865, and the Titanic struck an iceberg on April 14, 1912.
In “Oh, Mary,” a play at the Lyceum since 2024, the assassination is the climactic moment of a series of salacious jokes involving a homosexual affair, followed by a cabaret act. In “Titanique,” a musical that opened on Sunday at the St. James a block away, the Iceberg is a silvery draped drag diva who snaps a toy Titanic in half, but the characters survive and move to Las Vegas
Parodies on Broadway by Kathryn Holmes (Dance Magazine)
“Glancing at the list of musicals debuting on Broadway this spring might induce a feeling of cozy familiarity. Almost every premiere is based on a beloved movie, TV show, or older piece of theater. But take a closer look, and you’ll see that this particular dose of déjà vu comes with a twist. Among the retellings and revivals are several parodies, (Schmigadoon, Titanique)
Theater on TV by Jesse Green (NY Times)
“From the earliest kinescopes to cable and beyond, TV has never stopped offering stories about theater. “The Billy Rose Show,” an anthology of Rialto tales, including one in which Judith Anderson plays a stage actor on the skids, ran for 25 episodes on ABC starting in 1950. “American Classic,” starring Kevin Kline, also playing a stage actor on the skids, just finished its first season on the MGM+ streaming service. Despite so much practice, television still manages to get a few things wrong, specifically the process, the product and the people. (It occasionally manages to nail the excitement.) As seen on TV, plays are assembled in days, not years. Productions are unmitigated fiascos unless they’re star-making masterpieces. Actors are ridiculous, pathetic, needy and occasionally homicidal.”
Translating Theater by Gordon Cox (Jaques)
How AI-powered subtitle glasses, audio translation headsets, supertitles, and more open theater to global audiences
New Theater Seasons
BROADWAY
THE IMAGINARY INVALID
By Molière and Adapted by Bill Irwin
Directed by Brandon J. Dirden
Starring Bill Irwin
MIX AND MASTER
By Dominique Morisseau
Directed by Kamilah Forbes
Starring Ruben Santiago-Hudson and Kara Young
The last record shop in the Bronx is on its final spin. A rising DJ isn’t ready to let the music die.
THE FULL MONTY
Book by Terrence McNally; Music and Lyrics by David Yazbek
Choreographed by Connor Gallagher
Directed by Leigh Silverman
OFF-BROADWAY
THE HEART
Book and Additional Lyrics by Kait Kerrigan; Music and Lyrics by Anne Eisendrath and Ian Eisendrath
Choreographed by Mandy Moore
Directed by Christopher Ashley
A young surfer’s life is cut short. A stranger suddenly has a second chance. And the life-force of one beating heart drives two families and a medical team through 24 hours that couldn’t matter more.
THE GRIEF EATER NEAR NORTH BENDER
By Dylan Guerra
Directed by Dustin Wills
a grieving ex, his fiercely loyal sister, and a partner who can’t remember the man he loved join forces in a local pub to bring down a creature stalking the woods in this surreal comic fable
THE VAGINA MONOLOGUES
By V (formerly Eve Ensler)
Directed by Noma Dumezweni
PAC NYC 2026-27 season, (the theater-related offerings):
GIULIA: THE POISON QUEEN OF PALERMO (Musical Theater)
June 28 – July 26, 2026
What began as a single act of self-defense ripples through Palermo, creating a cascade of casualties and inspiring a secret sisterhood. But the path to safety is never safe. Can Giulia Tofana save them all without losing herself?
COME FROM AWAY IN CONCERT: SOUNDS OF REMEMBRANCE (Music)
September 13, 2026
Book, Music and Lyrics by Irene Sankoff & David Hein
A free, one-time-only concert event of the Tony® and Olivier Award-winning musical
A CHRISTMAS CAROL (Theater)
November 20, 2026—January 3, 2027
A version by Tony Award winner Jack Thorne
Conceived and Directed by Tony Award winner Matthew Warchus
DEMOCRACY CYCLE FESTIVAL (Event)
January 16-23, 2027
BAYE & ASA’S AT THE ALTAR (Dance)
THE PUERTO RICO EXPERIMENT (Music)
THE UNSINKABLE (Theater)
February 10 – March 7, 2027
By Frances Ya-Chu Cowhig
Directed by Aya Ogawa
When 17-year-old Little Fong is plunged into the freezing Atlantic as the Titanic sinks, survival becomes a battle inside his own mind. Inspired by the six Chinese seamen who lived—then were erased from the story of the Titanic’s survivors
THE GORGEOUS NOTHINGS (Musical Theater)
February 16 – March 14, 2027
Conceived & Written by Travis Lee Russ
Inspired by true events, The Gorgeous Nothings uncovers the long-buried story of the “Fag Ward,” a hidden wing of the Men’s Penitentiary on Welfare Island in New York City, where inmates were imprisoned in the 1930s for homosexuality
